José Antonio Saco is defined by being one of the first intellectuals who truly loved controversy, many of which he addressed with a passion aroused more by the act of polemicizing than by its own initial leitmotif. In this type of texts the best of his prose has remained, both for the logic of his arguments and for the extensive command of language, which acquired “plasticity” in his pen for the most diverse purposes.
Both in his press articles and in his essayistic-style texts, a fine sense of humor shines through that surprises with the use of purely Creole lexicons, the inclusion of ironic and even sarcastic phrases linked to what would be the joke in Caribbean literature, which is even more evident in his private correspondence, where he sheds all the formal clothing that implied contact with the general public.
On the political side, although he did not explicitly call for the initiation of armed struggle, he does seem to have been a lover of independence; although from his pragmatic philosophy he would not take on risky personal situations. This is directly intelligible in his own conceptions of Cuban nationality, a term that would be used and defined for the first time in his energetic prose, regarding annexationist adhesions that were already manifesting in the political-ideological spectrum of his time.
In this sense, he expressed: "As for me, although I know the immense advantages that Cuba would obtain with this peaceful incorporation into the United States, I must confess with all the candor of my soul, that I would have a reservation, a secret feeling for the loss of our Cuban nationality, (...) I want Cuba to be for the Cubans and not for a foreign race..." and he would affirm in another of his writings: "every people that inhabits the same soil, and has the same origin, the same language, and same uses and customs, that people have a nationality (…) To deny Cuban nationality is to deny the sunlight of the tropics at midday.
However, he suffered from the racial intolerance of his time and did not include black people or African roots as a structuring factor of nationality; This did not prevent him from seeing the substantial injustice of the slave trade and slavery, which served as the subject of several writings and historiographic volumes, a genre to which, in addition to the sagacity of his opinions, he bequeathed important contributions in terms of the management of a notable accumulation of information.
Part of his essayistic work, even without intending it, has a frank nuance of manners, as occurs with his text “Memory on Vagrancy on the Island of Cuba”, written in New York in 1830, in which he addresses most of the social problems that the colony suffered: vagrancy, begging, multiple vices that corroded the bowels of the nation, but, more than evils inherent to society or the Cuban idiosyncrasy, – others would try to distort these realities and present the Cuban as an inferior being from a social point of view – opportunely blames this on the deficient administration exercised by the colonial authorities.
The work of José Antonio Saco stands out for its Cubanness, not only for the ardent defense of nationality; but because his texts already outline the main personality and style traits of the Creole intellectual, who does not meditate from a cold distance from reality but rather engages with the object of study, reaching objectivity precisely through the subjectivity that he does not renounce conferring on his analyses.




