José de la Luz y Caballero (1800 – 1862), his philosophical and literary conceptions

16 September 2014 3 min read1790-1868 1 image

Luz y Caballero was the natural successor of Varela's ideas on philosophy and education. His basic concerns were related to the method of understanding science, which he considered should be both experimental and rationalist, leaving aside the bias of scholasticism.

Very interesting is his conception of the unity of all sciences, in a certain way divergent from the analytical Cartesian logic that led to the segmentation of problems and progressively of the fields of knowledge; This relational thinking is related to the principles of interdisciplinarity, which would emerge at a much later stage of epistemological development. He also stands out in this sense for having been a defender of controversy as a stimulus to the development of knowledge, and the valid coexistence of different perspectives on phenomena.

About his imprint, José Martí would write: "because he was a teacher and converted in a single generation a people educated for slavery into a people of heroes, workers and free men. He was able to be a lawyer, with a respectful and rich clientele, and his country was his only client. He was able to show off his copious science in the academies without effort, and he only showed what he knew about the truth, when it was essential to defend it. He was able to write in works - for his country at least - immortal, which, helping the sovereignty of his understanding with the piety of his heart, he learned in books and in nature, about the music of creation and the meaning of the world, and he did not write in books, which reward, but in souls, which tend to forget. He knew everything that was known in his time; but never to teach that he knew it, but to transmit it to men.

It is true that José de la Luz y Caballero received a truly encyclopedic training and possessed information and deep knowledge on various topics of science and the arts; But from a political point of view he did not play as active a role as his teacher Varela, although he was not a reactionary or defender of the most archaic colonial institutions, as he was sometimes unfairly described.

As a thinker he was conditioned by his membership in the emerging class of the Creole bourgeoisie, although his identification was not such that it prevented him from realizing the fundamental contradictions of the society of his time. On the one hand, he considered slavery as an evil; but he feared sudden abolition even with compensation. Likewise, he condemned colonial domination but was not openly pro-independence – nor, however, annexationist, a current that sometimes threatened to dominate the panorama of utopias and separatist projects – but rather reformist, an aspect on which certain hesitations would be revealed.

He was particularly interested in the philosophy of art, in this sense he believed in the existence of an infused gift, which could be cultivated through education but not implanted by it, he considered that art "is rooted in the heart of man and fertilized by the spectacle of the universe." Specifically in literature, he considered the scope of the national imagination as inserted in universal literature.

He liked to express his ideas in aphorisms; Although - consistent with his scientific ideas - he did not believe in literary precepts and gave equal merit to works from various currents, his critical texts were scarce and his literary preferences must be traced in selections and translations of the works of his contemporaries.