This story was published in the Havana magazine “El Album” in 1838, and with it the Cuban narrative acquired its own face both in terms of organicity, despite formal deficiencies - unusual length of the dialogues, problems in the management of temporal planes, hypertrophied function of the narrator, which denote the immaturity associated with the cultivation of the genre on the Island - and in regards to the locations and characters associated with the story.
The plot focuses on the drama of the seduction and subsequent oblivion of a rather middle-class young lady, Aurora, by a more tropical Don Juan, Claudio, who represents the type of bourgeois son fond of leisure that degenerates into vice, women and, above all, gambling. After seducing Aurora, he falls in love with Rosa Mirabel, who is married but reaches the limits of infidelity, stopped only by Aurora's fury who surprises them in a secluded area of the fields of San Marcos, about to give free rein to their passions.
In this situation, Rosa flees and Claudio restrains Aurora's screams, which threaten to create a very embarrassing situation for her. Due to the force applied by Claudio, Aurora faints and he flees, leaving her for dead. She survives and recovers after a period of convalescence, in which Claudio suffers remorse, added to the fears that his involvement in the events will be discovered and becomes willing to consent to the marriage, which they finally carry out but still end up separating years later and the protagonist dies sick, poor and vicious.
The text, with a frank moralizing intention, sparked controversy and received harsh criticism for the crude portrait of the ruffian, representative of a type that emerged from a social class that defended itself against its own miseries, and especially of the female characters, none of whom adhered to the ideal of virtue that was intended to be instilled at all costs in the young ladies of that time.
Likewise, the most contemporary criticism, even in its time, was noted to completely ignore the issue of slavery, presenting only the top of society. In the work, two or three black characters appear out of the corner of the eye, very much in the background, but the absence of their contradictions may suggest a false white preponderance.
Ambrosio Fornet says about the work: “Despite his inexperience, Palma managed to season the tired scheme of the Seducer and the Victim with all the ingredients of the genre: the cynical jokes of the libertine, the cunning naivety of the pimp, the torment of the defiled maiden, the astonishment of the astonishing events, the predictable moral... In a sequence like that of the horse runaway, the modern eye believes it even perceives the structure and rhythm of western films. But Palma wrote for another audience and did not take into account their low levels of tolerance, especially with regard to the institution of marriage and the conduct of women.
One might wonder whether or not the author had any awareness of the controversy that the text could arouse and of the detractors who would have the realistic brushstrokes with which he drew the characters, even without delving into any of the characters and within the rise of romantic narrative, to which he makes some concessions. The intrinsic literary value of the work is undeniable, with which the narrative acquires real aesthetic significance and captures vernacular topics.




