This novel was published in Madrid, using the pseudonym "A Cuban Magistrate", it is attributed to Antonio Franchi Alfaro although this assertion has not been fully elucidated, while at the same time there are not many studies on the text, undoubtedly important for some literary values, and above all for delving into the study of its historical circumstance.
The novel investigates the issue of legality in the colonial context, at the same time, this allows it to delve into the moral foundations on which the system was constituted and thus launch a critical attack on different “sick” areas of reality.
Throughout the work, a clear dichotomy is manifested between Félix Aristo, representative of honesty and in a general sense repository of an axiological content of absolute positive traits, and Perico Rustete, who reflects the everlasting tendency to place money and personal well-being above ethical considerations, through subterfuges and tricks of various kinds. Both embody extreme attitudes halfway between those of the true lawyers and jurists of the time.
This very contrasting conception of the characters, located at the uncontaminated poles of good and evil, somewhat nullifies the intention of revealing the social reality of their time, which however is expressed in broad strokes, especially in terms of the segregation of society into classes, evident in the stories of men of power, even belonging to high ecclesiastical and governmental strata, involved in various criminal acts. The emergence of certain passages linked to slavery or prostitution reflects the greater poverty and subjugation of the humble strata.
The novel responds in general terms to the romantic worldview, this is most evident in the idealized regeneration of the characters who jump to the pole of good without plausible motivations, which does not nullify a certain realism in the layout of the social panorama, as well as in the physiognomic and sometimes ethological description, when the author does not incur the Manichean bias.
According to Adis Barrio, "the transcendent meaning of the Forum... must be found in the disappointed and pessimistic aftertaste left by the certainty of justice sold to the highest bidder. This idea becomes conscious, to the extent that legality is accepted as a mere matter of luck." and quotes Franchi himself: “A sad spectacle is that of an honest man, fighting against luck and unable to overcome it.”
One of the possible readings points to an even sadder spectacle, that of a people oppressed by colonial injustice and without finally taking up arms to fight for freedom, since in all systems injustices are somehow connected.




