Main literary critics in the period 1844 – 1868

16 September 2014 3 min read1790-1868 1 image

Several names can be cited of those who more or less systematically issued critical opinions on literature, such as Joaquín Lorenzo Luaces (1826 - 1867) and José Fornaris (1827 - 1890), the latter was the author of an essay entitled "Will it be necessary to be a poet to be a critic?", in which he pointed out the need for extensive epistemological and cultural background to assume this role, his thesis is that it is not necessary to be a poet to practice criticism. which, although valid, is not fully argued. However, it maintains the preeminence of a special artistic sensitivity to fulfill such a function.

Nicolás Azcárate (1828 – 1894), host of numerous gatherings in which literary themes almost always emerged, was also president of the literary discussions section of the Liceo de Guanabacoa, from where he contributed to giving motility to the critical exercises, rather through the dissemination and not the “suppression” of certain works. His texts are rather chronicles of the theatrical field, although he also contributed to polishing the taste for poetry, through the dissemination of the most relevant voices of the moment, which he knew how to penetrate quite successfully.

For its part, the critical work of Rafael María de Mendive (1821 – 1886) – which was not extensive at all – is characterized by delving into the details of particular texts, without seeking correlations or risking a panoramic view, either in time or space, of certain areas.

Juan Clemente Zenea (1832 – 1871) also dealt with criticism, his vision points to the analysis, both formal and with respect to the content, of the works, at the same time that he proposes the need to know all the possible literary production, whether national or international, to place the object of analysis in a certain context, only then would its authentic values ​​emerge on the indicated levels. As a poet, he highlighted the need to thoroughly understand the elements of rhyme and rhythm, as well as strophic structures, all from the point of view of the expression of content through form, as an indivisible duality.

Ramón Zambrana (1817 – 1866) clung to scholasticism, unable to assimilate the new literary theories. He considered art only as a matter of aesthetic pleasure, leaving out the fertile terrain of content and ideologies. Throughout his production, most of which were texts included in fiery controversies, an imposing spirit was evident that damaged the reception of his criteria by authors and readers.

Ramón de Palma (1812 – 1860) continued to exert his influence at this stage, not only in the field of narrative, of which his text “Cantares de Cuba” is testimony, where he comes to consider the poet a social class, and delves into the study of peasant poetry and its manifestation through the tenth. It already refers to the social function of literature; although it ignores the role of the poet's personal experience, his own subjectivity, beyond any mark of collective identity.

These first critics, around the figure of Enrique Piñeyro, contributed to the development of a perspective specific to national literary production, as well as this as a separate theoretical space, although closely linked, with literary creation.