Although there were glimpses of literary criticism in the period before 1820, it was not until the period that extended from this date until approximately 1844, when the cultivation of criticism took root. It is true that this was often done based on rather cursory literary comments, inserted in publications on cultural topics or others that had sections dedicated to literature, the epistolary exchange between figures who were clearly more creators than critics, in all these spaces intuition predominated over the domain of technical elements.
In terms of genres, poetry criticism was generally quite behind with respect to the quality of the island's creations; the dogmatic vision and neoclassicism prevailed as the only artistic possibility, a situation suffered by Heredia and other romantics such as José Jacinto Milanés, around whom the harshest controversies broke out.
Narrative criticism had the advantage of practically assisting the gestation of the genre and influencing the creative process itself with its generally more accurate postulates, which occurs for example with Ramón de Palma, who, in addition to creating his own narrative pieces, dedicated himself to the analysis of the first narratives of Cirilo Villaverde.
For his part, Buenaventura Pascual Ferrer had initiated a hypercritical line, at the same time without true consistency in terms of assumptions, whose attacks were even directed against the authors' own personalities. This critical style lacked a minimum systemic conception and validity to access the substance of the works that served as targets; it has even been said that more than a literary attitude it denoted a Hispanophile political position.
In reality, the center of the web of texts close to criticism in the period, whether “official” as they expressed their criteria in the public light of the press, or in the private exchange of correspondence, was the personality of Domingo del Monte. “The figure that dominates the literary criticism of the period, and not precisely only with his written work, is Domingo del Monte, cultured, skillful, eclectic (…) with his own texts, or those of others that he stimulated and influenced, and even through private opinions, many of which we detect in his epistolary, he managed the basic threads of the development of literary criticism of the moment.”
Some texts with a more theoretical than critical approach would emerge at the stage, which would contribute to forming a cognitive corpus on literature as a field of value judgments. In 1832 Heredia published “Essay on the Novel” in Mexico, and an article by Domingo del Monte also appeared in Cuba, titled “Historical Novel,” in which he reviews three narratives of this nature. Antonio Bachiller y Morales, and José Jacinto Milanés, from their respective fields, also made some contributions; both knew how to assess early the renewal associated with romanticism.
Criticism was the terrain of the most bitter controversies, which went beyond the limits of what is properly literary to explore the terrain of ideological conflicts, so difficult to express directly given the ironclad colonial censorship. Beyond erratic judgments and inaccuracies, she would occupy a relevant position as an assistant to literary creation itself, an effective mediator between the author and the general public.




