The so-called satirical criticism had its main exponent on the Island in Emilio Bobadilla, along with Aniceto Valdivia. He dedicated himself more to the exercise of literary criticism itself than to theorizing about it. In fact, his works lack a solid theoretical conception that bases the opinions he issues, which were generally incisive and tended to detect errors and insufficiencies, like spots in the light, rather than to offer a general assessment of the texts.
Bobadilla professed separatist ideas that led him to leave the Island and travel extensively through Europe and America, in accordance with the most repressive colonial situations. In Europe he was imbued with positivist postulates and particularly in Spain he had contact with the burlesque criticism that he would imitate in much of his production.
Within this, the texts that had the greatest significance, despite the arbitrary nature of their judgments, were: “Reflejos de Fray Candil”, from 1886, “Escaramuzas”, from 1888, “Capirotazos”, 1890, “Triquitraque”, 1892, “Solfeo”, 193 and “Baturrillos”, from 1895, where he displays an erudition that would not be truly profound. and attacks pieces by numerous authors.
One of his most superficially satirical writings was the one he conceived as an excessive response to a criticism made by Enrique José Varona of his book “Reflejos de Fray Candil.” The text was titled “Varona… or whatever comes out,” whom he described as “domine with goggles and palmette.” Manuel de la Cruz and Manuel Sanguily came to Varona's defense, both measured but without failing to point out Bobadilla's unhealthy audacity and his lack of sobriety in the analysis of the texts.
Later he would return to the figure of Varona, commissioned by the critic José del Perojo, for the magazine “Nuevo mundo”, this time he would recognize some virtues but without ceasing to risk certain biting phrases.
He took his harsh attitude to the point of referring harshly to the works of the Spaniards Leopoldo Alas and Emilia Pardo Bazán, who had helped him enter the literary spheres of Spanish society. Despite these biases, a more in-depth study of his work still needs to be carried out to determine its successes.
There were few authors who escaped his condemnatory trials, among those chosen was Juan Clemente Zenea, to whom he even dedicated some elegiac verses in 1897, focused above all on the tragicity of the bard's death but where he inserted some evaluation of his poetics:
“You were young and an artist,
And your soldier judges
Ruthless, witless and backward,
The liver pregnant with resentments,
And among your compatriots, who was there?
That, like you, he cried his pains
In verses of such deep poetry?




