Rafael María Merchán (1844 – 1905), his foray into literary criticism

18 September 2014 2 min read1868-1898 1 image

Rafael María Merchán was also one of the Cuban literary critics who strongly adhered to the independence movement; assuming this political stance sometimes as an aesthetic sieve, so his texts do not always denote objectivity. In his youth he worked as a typographer and typesetter and these were his first contacts with the universe of the written word.

In addition to his political efforts, part of which have been addressed in the oratory section, he left interesting critical reflections, the ideological core of which can be found in his two main texts: “Critical Studies”, published in 1876 and “Variedades”, in 1894, both in Colombia, a country where he had apparently settled since 1874 or between the following two years and where he carried out part of his political work and literary criticism.

Some of his opinions were expressed in the context of a bitter controversy that he had with the Spanish critics Juan Valera and Vicente Barrantes, with the latter the reason being an article published by him in the newspaper “España moderna”, apologetic with respect to the book “Lyrical poetry in Cuba”, by Martín González del Valle, a Cuban living in Spain, which denigrated Cuban poetry and implicitly nationality.

In short, Merchán responds with an ironic article, titled “El espinar cuba y la segur barrantina” in which he correctly points to the extra-literary factors that had determined a certain delay in the evolution of Cuban poetry, in essence the Spanish colonial siege, also imposed on the development of ideas and which also weighed on collective subjectivity.

Within the framework of this controversy, he published another article of the same nature, under the title of “Everything”, in which he dedicated himself to valuing the historical and also literary stature of José de la Luz y Caballero, about whom many texts were written tending to overshadow his true revolutionary character.

It is worth mentioning other texts by the author that reveal interesting successes: “Poems of Juan Clemente Zenea”, “Stalagmites of language”, “Bécquer and Heine” and “The seven treatises of Montalvo”. In the texts cited and in the introductory notes of some books that he prefaced, many of his aesthetic paths can be traced, in which formalism and an sometimes exacerbated analytical predisposition prevailed.