The cultivation of literary criticism by Nicolás Heredia (1855 – 1901)

18 September 2014 2 min read1868-1898 1 image

Nicolás Heredia, in addition to his narrative texts “A businessman” and “Leonela”, also worked as a literary critic; Although on some occasions he described himself as an impressionist, the truth is that in his critical texts he does not limit himself to transmitting mere immediate aesthetic perceptions from reading the works, but is capable of delving into the core of the plot and establishing correlations with the literary currents in vogue and the relevant historical context.

It is true that his ideas adhered quite closely to what had already been established in terms of literary criticism - he was not in this sense a renovator - but he still presented interesting ideas, all of them nuanced by his intellectual modesty and the desire to point out the values ​​of the works and motivate the cycle of writing and reading in a general sense.

In 1892, Nicolás Heredia published the book “Points of View”, which brings together a series of speeches that he gave at the Liberal Youth Circle and at the Liceo de Matanzas. As part of this, both works created on the Island and those that were already emerging as valuable for universal literature constitute objects of analysis. It is worth mentioning the works of Julián del Casal and Enrique Piñeyro; as well as that of the naturalist Emile Zolá.

Regarding Enrique Piñeyro; although he refers imprecisely, in a tone that suggests a certain censorship, to his rather cold style and devoid of rhetorical and effective resources, praises the elegance of his prose and the fluidity of the style, which he does not consider "that of everyone" as Aniceto Valdivia had come to affirm with a certain frivolity.

His opinions on Julián del Casal, whom he considered rather a master of the form, demonstrate that this critic and, in a general sense, Cuban scholars had not correctly valued the renewing function of modernism not only as a foreign literary current but also its possibilities of reflecting national problems.

He also bequeathed some judgments about the colonial theater, with respect to which he criticized the implementation of foreign trends and, as was recurrent, the buffo theater, which he also considered imported, perhaps due to its links with Spanish humorous dramaturgy.

The critical work of Nicolás Heredia, although it was not excessively deep or systematic, was very positive due to its measured tone and the vision indicated by his practices regarding the need to encourage artistic creation instead of discouraging it.