The empty smile, by Francisco José Castellanos (1892 – 1920)

23 September 2014 2 min read1899-1958 1 image

“The Empty Smile” was a text published in 1915 by Francisco José Castellanos, although its thesis is political, it appears wrapped in a philosophy of life that opens to multiple readings. It gives a fundamental value to “construction” as a way of life, the man who builds his time and configures his reality, permanently, but not like Sisyphus and in this sense it is the reverse of the myth and where the author's optimism lies.

He proposes as an ideal of conduct: "Fight in oneself the intransigent being, the angry sensitivity; weave, higher than everything we do, and further away, in the inaccessible distance, the network of light in which what is yours and what everyone else converges, as in the same thought (...) raise as much as possible the joy and enthusiasm of that strength and that youth: the value of life."

His conception of the collective and the individual, concomitant in the same course of human actions, is also appreciated in the text; as well as the ideological breadth in which the author moves, his purpose of overcoming all antitheses (success – failure, individual – society, etc.), which sometimes leads to a language that is difficult to decipher, whose ultimate meaning may not have been fully revealed.

As a prefiguration of his political thesis, the author refers to the sincerity of the Cuban, to his dedication; apparently in relation to the northern neighbor; but without explicit references, although his advice to “not abandon our property, because we are incapable of preserving it, to the upstart who ultimately usurps it from us” is eloquent.

In the end, the “empty smile”, as a symbol, brings to light the theme of choteo, although implicitly – in this sense it is significant that it was precisely Jorge Mañach, author of “Indagación del choteo”, who later rescued this text in “Revista de Avance” – the sometimes contagious laughter with childish roots, which is ultimately a mask of frustration when one has stopped “building”, in this context perhaps already with the meaning of fighting.

The text ends with this phrase: "...to defeat apparent values is to give life its legitimate values. And when you have demolished, and sunk, and cast down, what rises from the rubble will be yourselves."

It shows how in his worldview the antitheses are annulled, in this case the one given by the poles of “construction – destruction.” The political reading, which is anchored to numerous allusions, can extend from the change of values ​​to the change of system, a transmutation that is linked to the renewing efforts that poets like Regino maintained at that time. Eladio Boti and José Manuel Poveda, still without a clear ideological definition.