The ideas, journalism and oratory of José Manuel Mestre (1832 – 1886)

16 September 2014 2 min read1790-1868 1 image

José Manuel Mestre studied Philosophy at the University of Havana, as well as disciplines linked to jurisprudence, eventually becoming a lawyer. He was particularly interested in the Philosophy of Law. He was a disciple of José de la Luz y Caballero, from whom he learned the concepts of the principle of duty as the guiding principle of human conduct, which was quite deep-rooted in part of the young generation of his time.

His philosophical theses, some of them manifest in “Considerations on Pleasure and Pain” that he presented to opt for a professorship in the Faculty of Philosophy, point towards the need for unlimited human development in all spheres, which were contracted by slavery and colonialism. It gives a fair place to historical research as a way to understand the present and promote the future. His philosophical position is eclectic in nature, like many of his predecessors such as Félix Varela himself, based on the positivist paradigm.

Like Francisco de Frías, he first adhered to annexationism and then to reformism; although more for a temporary issue since apparently he never sincerely believed in the viability of the reformist requests.

His journalistic work shows a wide cultural heritage as well as effectiveness in the mastery of language, which reveals his careful readings, both scientific and literary, in a period when the borders between both profiles were not definitively drawn.

His command of the language also extended to the field of oratory, where the speech given at the Cooper Institute, in New York, on the occasion of the fourth anniversary of October 10, is interesting. At this time he was in charge of representing the Republic in Arms in New York, following the death of José Morales Lemus, and the speech was part of a general strategy that proposed diplomatic recognition of the belligerence of the insurgents by the United States, with whose own feat of liberation from English colonialism he established a parallel.

His work at the head of the representation of the Republic in Arms had a conciliatory tone and compliance with the authority of Carlos Manuel de Céspedes, not because he especially sympathized with the leader but because he understood the importance of discipline and order to carry out the war effort to a successful conclusion. However, he never radicalized his thinking in line with the guiding ideals of the War and, faced with its failure, he chose to return to his thesis of science as the true engine of social progress.