The forays into literary criticism of Rafael Montoro (1852 – 1933)

18 September 2014 2 min read1868-1898 1 image

Rafael Montoro, while he stood out in the political oratory practiced in his time, also as an academic he conceived important speeches and conferences for art and island literature, many of his ideas are excellently expressed in his text "Music before the philosophy of art", to which are added others in which critical judgments worthy of attention are interspersed.

His piece “Realism in the face of dramatic art” is interesting insofar as it vindicates the need to study the genre and provide some prescriptive guidelines on its cultivation and appreciation. The judgments he makes in fact have implications for other genres, they go beyond him and have long been a source of polarized reflection, such as his conception that art should focus on beauty and ignore social eschatology, to name in some way all the negative things that afflicted society in the physical and moral spheres.

In the prologue to a work by Aurelio Mitjans published posthumously, “The scientific and literary movement of the island of Cuba,” Montoro assumes that Africanism was undermining Cuban theater, a judgment in which a certain racism and the fact of aspiring to dramatic motifs imported from Europe are latent. He was also concerned about the public's attitude towards the reception of panel art.

Some of his critical exercises have impressionist traces and a rhetoric that imitates literature itself, as is the case of the text titled “Alfredo de Musset”, in which he studies in few pages the life and work of the French poet and narrator.

Montoro had achieved some recognition in Spain, where he lived throughout the decade of the Ten Years' War, between 1868 and 1878. In a dissertation by the Spanish writer and academic Francisco de Paula Canalejas, entitled "Dramatic poetry in Spain", he several times refers to Montoro's ideas on literature, such as his fear of "the intrusion of the government into the sacred spheres of thought" and also mentions "the brilliant vehemence of Mr. Montoro, rich in inspirations, whenever he pays attention to the most noble ideas of science, freedom and progress."

Despite somewhat reducing the Cuban cultural universe to the European and particularly Spanish heritage, he did not fail to recognize the works of José María Heredia, Gertrudis Gómez de Avellaneda and Gabriel de la Concepción Valdés (Plácido) as having high lyrical flight, comparable to the best poetic pieces created on the European continent, and to worry about the development and reception of native literature.